Close Minded
Wednesday, August 26th, 2009 by Matt
Over the past year I’ve been told I’m many things. One of these things was being “closed minded.” Often this came from the fact that I didn’t believe the same thing as someone else. An example of this is me not believing in animal rights, or not believing in a god. I am closed minded because I don’t believe what the other person believes. But isn’t it closed minded of them for believing in something, and not accepting an alternative?
I believe in things that are presented to me with valid evidence. If someone tells me they saw a ghost, I will say “prove it.” If I was “open minded” and believed that someone who told me they saw a ghost I could have simply believed a lie. I would then accept that lie and make a claim that “ghosts are real because someone told me they saw one.” Without actually seeing the ghost, I am taking someone else’s belief and using it as my own without any evidence to back up why I believe in ghosts. Such is the case with religion, I was never presented with any proof of a god therefore I will not believe in a god.
For some people being open minded means that I have to agree with them. On the contrary, if I were to agree with everybody I wouldn’t have my own opinion about a subject. There can’t be a world were everyone believes in everything, there will always be someone who disagrees with you. One person also can’t believe in two things that contradict. For example a Catholic who believes in Evolution. However you have people who have two ideas that contradict, and when they argue with you they try to make a valid point. When you disagree with them, they call you closed minded.
Is it bad to be closed minded? Having an open mind can be a really bad thing. If you are a judge, who are you going to believe? If the judge was open minded he would believe both people. But in the real world someone needs to make a decision with proof. If one person can proove that they didn’t do what they are being charged for then they are free to go. However if they can’t proove it chances are they are guilty and have to be sent to prison.
So am I closed minded for believing in what I believe? Yes and no, I don’t let people tell me something and accept it as fact. If someone can provide me evidence for believing in then I will consider it before accepting it.









